6 Comments
User's avatar
Marc's avatar

From my observation and reading, there are three distinct types of "homeless" people: 1) those who are down on their luck financially who have been functioning but have exhuasted their resources, 2) those who are drug addicts without financial resources, and 3) people who have severe mental issues leaving them unable to function effectively. I propose that those in #1 be given immediate attention and assistance. I believe those described in #2 and #3 be taken from the street and moved to appropriate treatment facitlies.

In my opinion, it is inhumane to allow anyone to "live" on the streets. It affects all people particularly the taxpayers who fund all services and deserves safety and cleanliness.

The current systems have too many structural elements withour a clear directive for who is being served. In my opinion, the taxpayers drive this bus and are not being served. Every previous designed solution was deemed to be desirable and effective yet no one has been held responsible for failures. The insanity continues.

ERVIN SIVERSON's avatar

I frame the three homeless groups as The Have Nots, The Can Nots, and The Will Nots. We cannot keep treating all three groups as the same, that is failed policy. Rank Dr. Sharon Meieran #1 and don’t rank Shannon Singleton at all if you want change.

Paul Douglas's avatar

This is why I voted for Sharon Meieran. She's one of the few voices of rationality in dealing with homelessness after a decade of the Kafoury/JVP debacle, which has been a huge contributor to the fiscal and quality of life Doom Loop Multnomah County is now facing.

Connie McClellan's avatar

The next step is to put this excellent report side-by-side with Sharon Mieran's plan. The capstone of Mieran's plan is the "Homelessness to Housing Planning and Command Center"— kind of a grand coalition of all the local governmental entities involved. The "before" and "after" org charts in her plan illustrate to anyone who has tried to get their work done in a bureaucracy that the putting this plan into action will involve innumerable power struggles and territory defending. These will be motivated by natural and reasonable fears about positions and funding.

https://static1.squarespace.com/static/69d9472022ed8f4d832199ac/t/6a03b8ccc3ccac52f108ad2b/1788200109929/Comprehensive+Multnomah+County+Turnaround+Plan+-+2-6-26+update.pdf

And so my immediate take is that the "Command Center" should be established first as a tiny pilot phase but with competent leadership. As sources of friction make themselves clear, the Center can start building an implementation plan and perhaps going ahead with any low-hanging fruit that presents itself. It's a plan that needs to evolve rather than be frog-marched into place/

As for the overall theme of the report, I think it was Eric Zimmerman who told me at the 2024 D4 conference at Lincoln High School that when it comes to homelessness approaches, there's major tension between the city's mandate to provide housing the county's mandate of just keeping people alive.

Joe McAvoy's avatar

As long as we continue to misdiagnose the presence of drug addled and/or mentally ill persons on our streets as one of ‘homelessness’, we will continue to fail In our efforts to 1) make our streets safe and clean and 2) help those who are out suffering there on those streets. As much as I appreciate the summary that this article provides, there is nothing new here. We’ve been going round and round on this issue and we are getting nowhere. The only realistic approaches I have seen on this problem come from Thomas Dodson’s pieces here in the NWE.

Thomas Dodson's avatar

While I agree in theory, in practice unified leadership might be a failure as well. It depends a lot on the policies of the leadership. Civil commitment for six weeks to local community hospital acute psychiatric care means a serious rethink of mental health policy and law. The law is not in place to address the issues with the severely mentally ill on the street and in the community. Strengthening criminal justice and mental health and having them work together at times to achieve results is better. Forced psychiatric care hasn't been proven to be any better or worse than voluntary treatment. Both can be quite helpful in returning people to reasonable social and personal responsibility. And a strong outpatient mental health system along with police transport to hospitals when people decompensate is critical. Stop diverting people into mental health treatment. Prosecute them. Then commit them for up to six weeks for mental health treatment. A civil commitment procedure which houses the judicial hearings in local hospitals will drive occupancy in those hospitals. A lot of people think the long-term savings will be better than housing them without treatment which will lead to property destruction, criminality, and more death and deteriorating illness. Stop excluding people with mental illness. Hold them accountable to public laws, force care when necessary for safety, civility, and beauty in the public square. Force care when it would be inhumane not to do so. Limit commitment to six weeks. Housing only when they have demonstrated compliance with sobriety and mental health care recommendations. And then only when it is absolutely necessary. Legalize police transport to the ER when the officers believe the individual has a severe mental illness and because of illness is negatively affecting safety, civility, or beauty in the public square or that it would be inhumane not to intervene for the persons welfare.