"Meanwhile, I have finally managed to elect Eli Arnold to the Portland City Council. All it took was redrawing the city, changing the electoral rules, and rerunning the ballots on my computer. " Nixon vs McGovern... Bush vs Gore... The Village Idiot vs Kamala... Man, if I could pull off that trick I would have changed history!
What a travesty! Robert, thank you. While I consider myself to be an educated man, I still do not understand the distinctions you identified. Portland's voting methodolgy seems flawed to me. Not only did Mitch G win in 2024, he apparently benefited by incumbency.
I met and spoke with Eli Arnold at the Vista Viaduct celebration; he is a humble man and a capitalist. He made no attempt to brandish his service to our country.
The fact that Portland elected a DSA member and a polic-basher (this is as civil as I can be), is testimony for me of how rotten Portland political life is.
Haven't heard recall suggested. An election held to fill one vacant seat would seem to break out of the 25% threshold that favors small but ardent voting blocs. Anyone out there know more about this?
This is my understanding: To force a recall election, petitioners must collect valid signatures equal to 15% of the votes cast for governor in the district during the most recent gubernatorial election.
If the recall succeeds, the remaining City Council members can appoint a replacement by majority vote. If less than one year remains in the original term, the appointee would serve the remainder of that term. If one year or more remains, the appointee would serve until a replacement is elected at the next eligible general election, provided it occurs at least 120 days after the vacancy.
Because that election would fill only one seat, it would use single-winner ranked-choice voting rather than the proportional system used in regular three-seat council elections. A candidate receiving more than 50% of first-choice votes would win immediately. Otherwise, the lowest-placing candidates would be eliminated in successive rounds, with votes transferring to voters’ next available choices until a candidate receives a majority of the remaining active votes.
Although this strategy might work, I suspect many voters would view using a recall to overturn the outcome of a legitimate election as dirty politics and would be reluctant to sign the petition. I have zero respect for Green, but I wouldn’t sign a recall petition unless he actually did something “recall-worthy.” And winning an election fair and square is not “recall-worthy.”
In a normal election, yes, but I’m not convinced he would win in a head to head with Eli (the numbers presented here back that up) and simply will continue to be elected through the dubious math being utilized in the current debacle that is our ranked choice voting system. I’d sign a recall tomorrow if one were placed in front of me.
I also love data, but I think there’s a fundamental limitation to your simulation of 12 single-member districts. We have no idea what the candidate field would have looked like, how the campaigns would have been conducted, or how voters would have responded.
Your simulation demonstrates that changing the rules can change the outcome when you use the same ballots. It doesn’t tell us who would have won an actual election conducted under those different rules, although I think you acknowledge that limitation in your article.
I think a more interesting question is this: If District 4 were divided into three single-member districts, would DSA or similarly progressive voters be sufficiently concentrated in any one district to elect a candidate? Or would their support be spread across all three districts, leaving them without representation despite having substantial support throughout the larger district? That seems to me to be a more meaningful question about the tradeoffs between proportional representation and single-member districts.
As for the Chamber’s strategy in 2026, I think the explanation is much simpler. Clark and Green had strong constituencies, and the real competition for the remaining seat was between Zimmerman and Arnold. The Chamber preferred Zimmerman, so it made sense to concentrate its recommendations on him rather than divide support between the two. If voters followed that advice and ranked Zimmerman first, they would give him the strongest possible first-choice support.
You're right about the limitation, and I tried to say so in the piece. One clarification, though. I didn't simulate or average any votes. I used the actual 2024 cast vote records, the real rankings voters marked, kept every voter in their own precinct, and grouped the precincts into 12 contiguous districts. Each district was then counted as a single-winner ranked-choice race. What's modeled is the lines, not the votes. The main assumption is that each candidate runs in only one district, so some voters' rankings include candidates who wouldn't have been on their ballot. And it can't tell us who would have run, how they would have
campaigned, or how voters would have behaved in a one-seat race. It shows that with the same ballots, the rules change the answer.
Your question about concentration is the better one, and the model gives a first, rough answer. When I split District 4 into three seats, Green's voters were not concentrated enough to win any of them. They were concentrated enough to come close in one. In the district covering Downtown, South Portland and Ashcreek-Crestwood, Green lost to Arnold 47.5 to 52.5 in the final round. In a 13-district version he lost 48.1 to 51.9. Clark and Zimmerman took the other two seats.
So the tradeoff you describe shows up in the data. Under three-seat proportional voting, a constituency of roughly a quarter of the district gets a seat. Under single-member districts, the same voters spread across three seats and lose all three, narrowly in one. Which outcome is better is the real charter question. The arithmetic doesn't settle it, but it shows exactly what we'd be trading.
The next step would be to map Green's first-choice support precinct by precinct, to see whether different lines could produce a district he wins. If there's interest, I'll run it.
On the Chamber, I think we mostly agree. Its first two choices were elected. If Zimmerman was the priority, the strategy worked. My point was narrower: endorsing Arnold and prioritizing him are different things, and the ballots show the difference.
Ranked choice voting seems to have survived judicial challenges, so it appears to now be a common fixture among local and state elections. But the hybrid of ranked choice, combined with the utterly outlandish system used by the City of Portland where Council candidates coming in 2nd and 3rd in elections get to sit on the Council with equal voting power as the 1st place candidate, hits me as fundamentally undemocratic and an electoral version of extreme affirmative action to elevate minority views to majority status. I would love to see this outrageous arrangement challenged in the courts and find its way all the way to SCOTUS where I predict it would be found contrary to the U.S. Constitution.
So we should have ranked Olivia second and Eli first because we “knew” that everyone loves Olivia? I guess “they” can now include me when they say things like “the voters are too stupid to understand what they're doing”. 🤷♀️
BTW, I did meet Eli & had a conversation with him at that D4 conference we had at Lincoln HS in 2023 and was quite impressed.
"Meanwhile, I have finally managed to elect Eli Arnold to the Portland City Council. All it took was redrawing the city, changing the electoral rules, and rerunning the ballots on my computer. " Nixon vs McGovern... Bush vs Gore... The Village Idiot vs Kamala... Man, if I could pull off that trick I would have changed history!
What a travesty! Robert, thank you. While I consider myself to be an educated man, I still do not understand the distinctions you identified. Portland's voting methodolgy seems flawed to me. Not only did Mitch G win in 2024, he apparently benefited by incumbency.
I met and spoke with Eli Arnold at the Vista Viaduct celebration; he is a humble man and a capitalist. He made no attempt to brandish his service to our country.
The fact that Portland elected a DSA member and a polic-basher (this is as civil as I can be), is testimony for me of how rotten Portland political life is.
I am disgusted and looking for a new home.
Serious question - wouldn’t we have the numbers to recall Green if an organized effort were launched?
Haven't heard recall suggested. An election held to fill one vacant seat would seem to break out of the 25% threshold that favors small but ardent voting blocs. Anyone out there know more about this?
This is my understanding: To force a recall election, petitioners must collect valid signatures equal to 15% of the votes cast for governor in the district during the most recent gubernatorial election.
If the recall succeeds, the remaining City Council members can appoint a replacement by majority vote. If less than one year remains in the original term, the appointee would serve the remainder of that term. If one year or more remains, the appointee would serve until a replacement is elected at the next eligible general election, provided it occurs at least 120 days after the vacancy.
Because that election would fill only one seat, it would use single-winner ranked-choice voting rather than the proportional system used in regular three-seat council elections. A candidate receiving more than 50% of first-choice votes would win immediately. Otherwise, the lowest-placing candidates would be eliminated in successive rounds, with votes transferring to voters’ next available choices until a candidate receives a majority of the remaining active votes.
Although this strategy might work, I suspect many voters would view using a recall to overturn the outcome of a legitimate election as dirty politics and would be reluctant to sign the petition. I have zero respect for Green, but I wouldn’t sign a recall petition unless he actually did something “recall-worthy.” And winning an election fair and square is not “recall-worthy.”
In a normal election, yes, but I’m not convinced he would win in a head to head with Eli (the numbers presented here back that up) and simply will continue to be elected through the dubious math being utilized in the current debacle that is our ranked choice voting system. I’d sign a recall tomorrow if one were placed in front of me.
In a similar vein, did the cool kids who came up with the new city charter put term limits for city councilors in it?
Can we PLEASE get rid of rank choice voting! Favorite billboard: "Ditch Mitch"
I also love data, but I think there’s a fundamental limitation to your simulation of 12 single-member districts. We have no idea what the candidate field would have looked like, how the campaigns would have been conducted, or how voters would have responded.
Your simulation demonstrates that changing the rules can change the outcome when you use the same ballots. It doesn’t tell us who would have won an actual election conducted under those different rules, although I think you acknowledge that limitation in your article.
I think a more interesting question is this: If District 4 were divided into three single-member districts, would DSA or similarly progressive voters be sufficiently concentrated in any one district to elect a candidate? Or would their support be spread across all three districts, leaving them without representation despite having substantial support throughout the larger district? That seems to me to be a more meaningful question about the tradeoffs between proportional representation and single-member districts.
As for the Chamber’s strategy in 2026, I think the explanation is much simpler. Clark and Green had strong constituencies, and the real competition for the remaining seat was between Zimmerman and Arnold. The Chamber preferred Zimmerman, so it made sense to concentrate its recommendations on him rather than divide support between the two. If voters followed that advice and ranked Zimmerman first, they would give him the strongest possible first-choice support.
Thank you. Great comment.
You're right about the limitation, and I tried to say so in the piece. One clarification, though. I didn't simulate or average any votes. I used the actual 2024 cast vote records, the real rankings voters marked, kept every voter in their own precinct, and grouped the precincts into 12 contiguous districts. Each district was then counted as a single-winner ranked-choice race. What's modeled is the lines, not the votes. The main assumption is that each candidate runs in only one district, so some voters' rankings include candidates who wouldn't have been on their ballot. And it can't tell us who would have run, how they would have
campaigned, or how voters would have behaved in a one-seat race. It shows that with the same ballots, the rules change the answer.
Your question about concentration is the better one, and the model gives a first, rough answer. When I split District 4 into three seats, Green's voters were not concentrated enough to win any of them. They were concentrated enough to come close in one. In the district covering Downtown, South Portland and Ashcreek-Crestwood, Green lost to Arnold 47.5 to 52.5 in the final round. In a 13-district version he lost 48.1 to 51.9. Clark and Zimmerman took the other two seats.
So the tradeoff you describe shows up in the data. Under three-seat proportional voting, a constituency of roughly a quarter of the district gets a seat. Under single-member districts, the same voters spread across three seats and lose all three, narrowly in one. Which outcome is better is the real charter question. The arithmetic doesn't settle it, but it shows exactly what we'd be trading.
The next step would be to map Green's first-choice support precinct by precinct, to see whether different lines could produce a district he wins. If there's interest, I'll run it.
On the Chamber, I think we mostly agree. Its first two choices were elected. If Zimmerman was the priority, the strategy worked. My point was narrower: endorsing Arnold and prioritizing him are different things, and the ballots show the difference.
NW Examiner just can't stop publishing AI slop.
Ranked choice voting seems to have survived judicial challenges, so it appears to now be a common fixture among local and state elections. But the hybrid of ranked choice, combined with the utterly outlandish system used by the City of Portland where Council candidates coming in 2nd and 3rd in elections get to sit on the Council with equal voting power as the 1st place candidate, hits me as fundamentally undemocratic and an electoral version of extreme affirmative action to elevate minority views to majority status. I would love to see this outrageous arrangement challenged in the courts and find its way all the way to SCOTUS where I predict it would be found contrary to the U.S. Constitution.
So we should have ranked Olivia second and Eli first because we “knew” that everyone loves Olivia? I guess “they” can now include me when they say things like “the voters are too stupid to understand what they're doing”. 🤷♀️
BTW, I did meet Eli & had a conversation with him at that D4 conference we had at Lincoln HS in 2023 and was quite impressed.
Also, Eli was the victim of an unscrupulous , don't rank hit ad , as was Councilor Eric Zimmerman of Dist. 4
Both candidates were attacked by Mitch Green and his Campaign Treasure Monica Santoyo ,
Fronted by "For the People" PAC
Orestar Commitee ID 25356
look it up