Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Gerhard Magnus's avatar

"Meanwhile, I have finally managed to elect Eli Arnold to the Portland City Council. All it took was redrawing the city, changing the electoral rules, and rerunning the ballots on my computer. " Nixon vs McGovern... Bush vs Gore... The Village Idiot vs Kamala... Man, if I could pull off that trick I would have changed history!

David Mitchell's avatar

Ranked choice voting seems to have survived judicial challenges, so it appears to now be a common fixture among local and state elections. But the hybrid of ranked choice, combined with the utterly outlandish system used by the City of Portland where Council candidates coming in 2nd and 3rd in elections get to sit on the Council with equal voting power as the 1st place candidate, hits me as fundamentally undemocratic and an electoral version of extreme affirmative action to elevate minority views to majority status. I would love to see this outrageous arrangement challenged in the courts and find its way all the way to SCOTUS where I predict it would be found contrary to the U.S. Constitution.

12 more comments...

Ready for more?