The horror... When somebody other than nice white people and the business and real estate interests they represent tries to have real political power in Portland. The horror... the horror....
No, much better that 75% of the city feel totally unrepresented anywhere on their city council so special interest groups and a far left political party can run everything into the ground. You can just say you don’t believe in democracy and lean communist.
What are you talking about? When each counselor needs only a tiny fraction of the district to rank them, what happens to the rest of us?
I live in D4 and none of my current counselors or the likely future counselors live in my quadrant of town. How do they represent me? Why are my needs as a constituent less important than other parts of my district? Why do I not deserve representation?
Hamlet, you have identified one of the central problems I was trying to describe.
The defense of our present system is that all three councilors represent everyone in their district, regardless of where they live. That's true as a matter of formal responsibility. But it doesn't resolve the question of geographic accountability.
District 4 contains neighborhoods with very different needs. When none of the three councilors lives in a substantial part of that district, who is specifically accountable to the people living there? In theory, all three. In practice, that can mean nobody in particular.
I would also distinguish this from the claim that 75% of voters are unrepresented. That's not how the mathematics works, and it isn't my argument.
My argument is that representation ought to connect an identifiable electorate with an identifiable representative who must answer to those voters. That is why I favor smaller, single-member districts.
You have put your finger on the question the charter reform never adequately answered: representation of whom, and accountability to whom
Robert: The real test will come here: "The Independent District Commission would draw the real lines."
If it's as "independent" as the original Charter Commission, god help us. Any such commission will be named by the present councilors, media will ignore the process, and insiders will predominate.
I was (and am) angry, and I think I overstated my case. I don't think, necessarily, that 75% of the voters of a district are unrepresented--though it does feel like that, sometimes. I was agreeing with your premise, albeit from a very personal and very frustrated perspective.
The incentive structure is very clear. In 2024, the threshold for winning a seat on the city counsel as a representative of D4 was 19,180 votes. A little less than 16% of D4 voters returned ballots without voting for any city counsel candidates, so you wind up with a counselor getting a seat while representing some 12% of the district. Now, the people who show up are the ones who make the decisions, so that's life. But what we've ended up with is a system that incentivizes a counselor to find their pocket of highly motivated 20k voters and get them out every 4 years.
Speaking only for myself, this means that I may go some cycles before seeing a counselor darken my doorstep, asking for my support.
But I repeat myself. You are right, and I remain angry.
I am the one who commented that 75% of the residents are not represented so I think that’s what he was referring back to. I agree with your observations on this whole-heartedly, however, and threw 75% out there because, even considering low voter turnout, of those who did vote, the majority no longer rules if a candidate must simply capture 25% (and even then, they could have been ranked candidate #5 on the ballot and earned the vote through process of elimination). There are still a shocking number of people who don’t understand how ranked choice voting works. I also live in District 4 and it’s been pretty clear for the last two years that no one on the council has done much of anything to address the many issues we live with here. In fact, this council has managed to fall short of what was already a low bar.
The adults in the room knew full well that the proposed Charter Commission reforms would be an unmitigated disaster. It was as clear as it could have been to anyone who was well versed in municipal governance. And this PC-driven experiment in social engineering, which is in all likelihood unconstitutional, will effectively prevent the City of Portland from reversing its steady decline in virtually every aspect of urban life.
We live in neighborhoods within districts. The Supreme Court decision made this distinction. The plan created was purposely designed to ignore our neighborhoods in favor of interest groups defined by ethnicity or skin color. This choice was divisive and screamed "victimhood".
Eliminating the primary election might be the greatest triumph of the new system, hiding in plain sight. The primary election is a turnout destroyer.
I'm old, and maybe I loved the fact that the average age of a May primary voter is well over 60. But if we care about turnout for these elections, the primary election is a disaster.
Generally: STV is not brain surgery. The advantages could make a big difference. More districts mean more re-districting shenanigans. This system doesn't inherently favor the ideologues or destroy consensus.
I hope supporters recognize there is risk that STV will be unplugged. I see complacency. Someone persuasive needs to sell it. I'm disappointed that Olivia Clark is skeptical, and proponents need to worry.
The fix was in when the Charter Commission was "selected" and populated with government/union/NGO insiders; cemented when the executive director, Julia Meier, was moved from running the City Club and Coalition of Communities of Color to the Commission.
The legacy media--there were very few of us in Pirate Media back then--ignored the commission up to and after the vote. I wrote 27 stories on PortlandDissent, saying what Miller has said more elegantly, but we had 200 readers, and no one else was listening.
Portland voters did what they always do: voted with their hearts, not their heads.
There were also the small matters of antifa riots and Covid.
Miller has taken this a step forward and proposed real-world, doable solutions. I once wrote a piece (not nearly as good as Miller's), headlined "Who Will Bell the Cat." That challenge remains: who will lead the fight to undo the damage wrought by the forces that, essentially, created the system that can't even do what the conspiracy wanted to accomplish.
Unless everyone in Portland has gone mute--or broke--it's time to put up or shut up.
I’d like to recommend an article from the Sightline Institute from 2022 that better explains single transferable vote, proportionality, and how the charter commission arrived at our current voting method than the article above does:
The charter commission was informed by the work of mathematician Moon Duchin and her group MGGG (Metric Geometry and Gerrymandering Group) which at the time was based at Tufts University. Duchin and her rebranded group have since moved to the University of Chicago. Duchine is a well-respected mathematician and is doing cutting-edge research.
What’s my point? I guess that you all have created a nice little echo chamber for talking about this, but are missing the much wider discussion about gerrymandering and alternative voting methods that is happening nationally. For example, here’s the NYT’s Jamelle Bouie, from 2022:
"I agree! But I think we should go further. Even if you end partisan gerrymandering for House (and just as crucially state legislative) elections, you’re still left with the real culprit for many of our political dysfunctions: single-member districts and “first past the post” voting. As long as you elect single members by individual district, there is a risk of malapportionment. And as long as you have “first past the post” voting — where candidates can win with a plurality of the vote — there’s little to no chance that a third party could succeed in an election (something I explore in my most recent column).
One solution is just to get rid of districts altogether. Or if you’d prefer to keep districts, divide each state into a number of multi-member districts, in which voters elect multiple candidates using a form of preference voting. Ranked-choice voting has made some inroads here in the United States, but I am a fan of approval voting, in which voters can cast a vote for as many candidates as they’d like that are on the ballot. Whoever gets the most votes — or in a multi-member district, the top vote getters — wins a seat in Congress."
Thank you for the reading list, and I mean that; the Eberhard piece and the MGGG Portland report are the two documents the charter commission actually leaned on, and anyone who wants to argue about the method should start there. Two small corrections so the next reader finds them: the mathematician is Moon Duchin, and her group began at Tufts, not Rutgers, before it moved to Chicago as the Data and Democracy Lab. Her CV is on the group’s site.
On the substance. I have no quarrel with Duchin’s mathematics, and I do not think my piece has one. The MGGG report answers the question the commission asked it: which system gives Portland’s minority communities the best chance at seats. It answers that question well. My piece asks a different one: what the system does to a single district’s voters once the ballots are in, measured by exhausted ballots and by who ends up casting the deciding vote for the third seat. Those are not competing claims. They are two questions, and the commission only asked one of them.
On the echo chamber. You quote Bouie, and I would quote him back at you. He wants multi-member districts, which Portland has, and then he says he prefers approval voting, not ranked choice. So the national conversation you are pointing me toward is not a settlement in favor of Portland’s method. It is an open argument among people who agree the old system was broken and disagree about the replacement. That is the conversation I think I am in. If you have data that shows the D4 exhausted-ballot result is an artifact of my method rather than of the system, send it with the source and I will run it and print the result either way.
Hello Robert, thank you for replying. Basically, I disagree with what you are saying and reject your fix of nine districts and your "one vote per voter, and a majority to win." Under the ranked-choice voting, single-transfer voting system that we are currently using, a voter only gets one vote. Everybody gets one vote--that is how it is, that is fact. Anybody who doubts that can work through the transfers on this spreadsheet:
As far who funded the charter reform measure, and what the committee thought they were getting regarding representation of racial minorities--I agree with you. Portland is obsessed with race, and I think the committee members had an incorrect understanding of "minority" which was limited to racial/ethnic minorities.
Eberhard explains the more expansive definition of "minority" that multi-member districts and single-transferable vote captures:
"But single-winner districts only guarantee geographical representation. MGGG’s analysis proves that, in Portland, geography is not the same as race and ethnicity. Voters of color won’t have any more power in single-winner districts than they do in Portland’s winner-take-all at-large elections.
The report’s results hold true for other types of minority representation, too. Voters who prefer a champion for renters are in the minority, but because there isn’t a part of the city where all the renters live, districts won’t help. Same for people who are dependent on transit, those who get around by bike, youth, or parents of school-age children. Again, many issues of importance to Portlanders are not determined by geography. Proportional ranked choice voting allows voters to come together and support a candidate of choice based on what is important to them, no matter where they live within the city. If one-fifth of voters prefer a renters’ platform, proportional ranked choice voting will give them the power to elect at least one councilor out of five who will champion renters."
It's that definition of "minority" that your fixes do away with. And they move Portland back to a system where issues that large percentages of Portlanders care about don't win a voice in government.
"Now ask what that does to an independent voter. If your first choice gets a quarter of the district plus one, she is elected whether or not anyone coordinated. But an independent’s first choice almost never does, because independents don’t agree with each other about who that is. Twenty-one candidates ran in District 4, and the unaffiliated voters spread their first choices across most of them. A quarter of the district voting independently elects nobody. A quarter of the district voting in order elects one."
That's a head-scratcher. It seems like you are assuming that voters are random vote generators. 24.95% of D4 voters ranked Olivia Clark as their first choice; and then Green Arnold and Zimmerman clumped in at over 10% each. So your "unaffiliated voters spread their first choices across most of them" is technically correct, but ignores the more important fact of vote distribution. Votes were not spread evenly, they reflect strong voter-preference for Clark, Green, Arnold and Zimmerman.
On Clark we agree, so let’s not pretend otherwise. Your 24.95 percent is my figure in my copy, and she is exactly the case my sentence describes: a candidate whose first choices reach a quarter of the district wins a seat with no help from anyone. The other two seats in D4 were not won that way. They were decided by transfers, and transfers follow the order on the ballot, and in 2024 the order came from organized endorsement cards. Arnold had the most first choices of any challenger and lost on transfers. That is not a head-scratcher. That is the system working as designed.
So here is my position, stated once so no one has to guess at it.
Every voter gets one vote. I have never said otherwise. What I have said is that under this system a vote elects someone only if it is ranked in the order a machine has set. The voter with a card elects a councilor. The voter ranking on her own judgment watches her ballot exhaust before the last seat is filled. The 2024 D4 count shows it. I ran the ballots, I published the method, and I will print a correction the day anyone shows me the result is an artifact of my arithmetic rather than of the rules.
I have no quarrel with Duchin’s mathematics or with the MGGG report. It answered the question the commission asked. The commission did not ask the second question: who, inside the system, ends up holding the ranking pen. The Voting Rights Act standard is whether a group of voters can elect the candidate of their choice. In Portland today the group that can is the group with the best organized list. That is not what the voters were sold in 2022.
What I propose is plain. Nine single-member districts, one vote per voter, a majority to win, lines drawn by a commission the council does not appoint, and a mayor with the authority to be held responsible for results. There may be a better system than that. What we have is not it.
Why it matters for Portland, and not just for D4: a city where every councilor answers to a named neighborhood is a city where potholes, permits, and police response have an owner. A city where councilors answer to the groups that printed their ranking cards is a city where those groups own the agenda and no one owns the street. We have had two years of the second kind. Anyone who thinks it is working should say so in public and defend it. Anyone who agrees it is not should start on the charter language now, because the earliest ballot that can fix it is already close.
You conflate the rise of the DSA with the new voting method. But the DSA has been gaining seats across the country in areas that don't use single transferable vote in multi-member districts. So I don't see the causality being as tight as you do.
There is that saying that goes something like, "generals always fight the last war." Your piece is doing that, yet much has changed since the 2024 cycle: the mayor is actively and visibly supporting non-DSA candidates; GoPortlandGo has a slate; FuturePortland has a slate; Max Steele has changed the narrative of how the DSA is seen; you've done that too, give yourself credit; the Oregonian has even wised-up with their frank candidate endorsement piece; the candidates have changed how they are campaigning . . . there is a lot that is different this time round.
So let's give this new method a couple cycles for voters shake off their lazies and start paying attention to local politics, rather than doom-scrolling national/international news and giving a knee-jerk vote to the candidate who best expresses their anger.
You write "in 2024 the order came from organized endorsement cards" and give no supporting evidence. I'm not following much of your analysis. By definition, all ballots are exhausted by the time the last candidate wins. That's how voting works.
The horror... When somebody other than nice white people and the business and real estate interests they represent tries to have real political power in Portland. The horror... the horror....
No, much better that 75% of the city feel totally unrepresented anywhere on their city council so special interest groups and a far left political party can run everything into the ground. You can just say you don’t believe in democracy and lean communist.
What are you talking about? When each counselor needs only a tiny fraction of the district to rank them, what happens to the rest of us?
I live in D4 and none of my current counselors or the likely future counselors live in my quadrant of town. How do they represent me? Why are my needs as a constituent less important than other parts of my district? Why do I not deserve representation?
Yours is an absurd straw man argument. Grow up.
Hamlet, you have identified one of the central problems I was trying to describe.
The defense of our present system is that all three councilors represent everyone in their district, regardless of where they live. That's true as a matter of formal responsibility. But it doesn't resolve the question of geographic accountability.
District 4 contains neighborhoods with very different needs. When none of the three councilors lives in a substantial part of that district, who is specifically accountable to the people living there? In theory, all three. In practice, that can mean nobody in particular.
I would also distinguish this from the claim that 75% of voters are unrepresented. That's not how the mathematics works, and it isn't my argument.
My argument is that representation ought to connect an identifiable electorate with an identifiable representative who must answer to those voters. That is why I favor smaller, single-member districts.
You have put your finger on the question the charter reform never adequately answered: representation of whom, and accountability to whom
Robert: The real test will come here: "The Independent District Commission would draw the real lines."
If it's as "independent" as the original Charter Commission, god help us. Any such commission will be named by the present councilors, media will ignore the process, and insiders will predominate.
I was (and am) angry, and I think I overstated my case. I don't think, necessarily, that 75% of the voters of a district are unrepresented--though it does feel like that, sometimes. I was agreeing with your premise, albeit from a very personal and very frustrated perspective.
The incentive structure is very clear. In 2024, the threshold for winning a seat on the city counsel as a representative of D4 was 19,180 votes. A little less than 16% of D4 voters returned ballots without voting for any city counsel candidates, so you wind up with a counselor getting a seat while representing some 12% of the district. Now, the people who show up are the ones who make the decisions, so that's life. But what we've ended up with is a system that incentivizes a counselor to find their pocket of highly motivated 20k voters and get them out every 4 years.
Speaking only for myself, this means that I may go some cycles before seeing a counselor darken my doorstep, asking for my support.
But I repeat myself. You are right, and I remain angry.
I am the one who commented that 75% of the residents are not represented so I think that’s what he was referring back to. I agree with your observations on this whole-heartedly, however, and threw 75% out there because, even considering low voter turnout, of those who did vote, the majority no longer rules if a candidate must simply capture 25% (and even then, they could have been ranked candidate #5 on the ballot and earned the vote through process of elimination). There are still a shocking number of people who don’t understand how ranked choice voting works. I also live in District 4 and it’s been pretty clear for the last two years that no one on the council has done much of anything to address the many issues we live with here. In fact, this council has managed to fall short of what was already a low bar.
If people believe these are the motivations for the new system: it's doomed.
The adults in the room knew full well that the proposed Charter Commission reforms would be an unmitigated disaster. It was as clear as it could have been to anyone who was well versed in municipal governance. And this PC-driven experiment in social engineering, which is in all likelihood unconstitutional, will effectively prevent the City of Portland from reversing its steady decline in virtually every aspect of urban life.
Thank You For exposing The flaws.
Let's toss rank choice and go back to one district one representative. What were we thinking?
Thank you Robert.
We live in neighborhoods within districts. The Supreme Court decision made this distinction. The plan created was purposely designed to ignore our neighborhoods in favor of interest groups defined by ethnicity or skin color. This choice was divisive and screamed "victimhood".
Portland is not a healthy city.
Eliminating the primary election might be the greatest triumph of the new system, hiding in plain sight. The primary election is a turnout destroyer.
I'm old, and maybe I loved the fact that the average age of a May primary voter is well over 60. But if we care about turnout for these elections, the primary election is a disaster.
Generally: STV is not brain surgery. The advantages could make a big difference. More districts mean more re-districting shenanigans. This system doesn't inherently favor the ideologues or destroy consensus.
I hope supporters recognize there is risk that STV will be unplugged. I see complacency. Someone persuasive needs to sell it. I'm disappointed that Olivia Clark is skeptical, and proponents need to worry.
The fix was in when the Charter Commission was "selected" and populated with government/union/NGO insiders; cemented when the executive director, Julia Meier, was moved from running the City Club and Coalition of Communities of Color to the Commission.
The legacy media--there were very few of us in Pirate Media back then--ignored the commission up to and after the vote. I wrote 27 stories on PortlandDissent, saying what Miller has said more elegantly, but we had 200 readers, and no one else was listening.
Portland voters did what they always do: voted with their hearts, not their heads.
There were also the small matters of antifa riots and Covid.
Miller has taken this a step forward and proposed real-world, doable solutions. I once wrote a piece (not nearly as good as Miller's), headlined "Who Will Bell the Cat." That challenge remains: who will lead the fight to undo the damage wrought by the forces that, essentially, created the system that can't even do what the conspiracy wanted to accomplish.
Unless everyone in Portland has gone mute--or broke--it's time to put up or shut up.
I’d like to recommend an article from the Sightline Institute from 2022 that better explains single transferable vote, proportionality, and how the charter commission arrived at our current voting method than the article above does:
https://www.sightline.org/2021/09/22/want-to-give-portlanders-of-color-a-voice-on-city-council-districts-wont-help/
The charter commission was informed by the work of mathematician Moon Duchin and her group MGGG (Metric Geometry and Gerrymandering Group) which at the time was based at Tufts University. Duchin and her rebranded group have since moved to the University of Chicago. Duchine is a well-respected mathematician and is doing cutting-edge research.
Once you’ve read the Sightline article by Kristin Eberhard, read the MGGG analysis of Portland voting that the article links to: https://mggg.org/publications/Portland.pdf. (And if you are really, really ambitious, try reading about the math behind it: https://mggg.org/uploads/ReCom.pdf)
What’s my point? I guess that you all have created a nice little echo chamber for talking about this, but are missing the much wider discussion about gerrymandering and alternative voting methods that is happening nationally. For example, here’s the NYT’s Jamelle Bouie, from 2022:
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/30/opinion/senate-house-power.html?referringSource=articleShare
"I agree! But I think we should go further. Even if you end partisan gerrymandering for House (and just as crucially state legislative) elections, you’re still left with the real culprit for many of our political dysfunctions: single-member districts and “first past the post” voting. As long as you elect single members by individual district, there is a risk of malapportionment. And as long as you have “first past the post” voting — where candidates can win with a plurality of the vote — there’s little to no chance that a third party could succeed in an election (something I explore in my most recent column).
One solution is just to get rid of districts altogether. Or if you’d prefer to keep districts, divide each state into a number of multi-member districts, in which voters elect multiple candidates using a form of preference voting. Ranked-choice voting has made some inroads here in the United States, but I am a fan of approval voting, in which voters can cast a vote for as many candidates as they’d like that are on the ballot. Whoever gets the most votes — or in a multi-member district, the top vote getters — wins a seat in Congress."
Thank you for the reading list, and I mean that; the Eberhard piece and the MGGG Portland report are the two documents the charter commission actually leaned on, and anyone who wants to argue about the method should start there. Two small corrections so the next reader finds them: the mathematician is Moon Duchin, and her group began at Tufts, not Rutgers, before it moved to Chicago as the Data and Democracy Lab. Her CV is on the group’s site.
On the substance. I have no quarrel with Duchin’s mathematics, and I do not think my piece has one. The MGGG report answers the question the commission asked it: which system gives Portland’s minority communities the best chance at seats. It answers that question well. My piece asks a different one: what the system does to a single district’s voters once the ballots are in, measured by exhausted ballots and by who ends up casting the deciding vote for the third seat. Those are not competing claims. They are two questions, and the commission only asked one of them.
On the echo chamber. You quote Bouie, and I would quote him back at you. He wants multi-member districts, which Portland has, and then he says he prefers approval voting, not ranked choice. So the national conversation you are pointing me toward is not a settlement in favor of Portland’s method. It is an open argument among people who agree the old system was broken and disagree about the replacement. That is the conversation I think I am in. If you have data that shows the D4 exhausted-ballot result is an artifact of my method rather than of the system, send it with the source and I will run it and print the result either way.
Hello Robert, thank you for replying. Basically, I disagree with what you are saying and reject your fix of nine districts and your "one vote per voter, and a majority to win." Under the ranked-choice voting, single-transfer voting system that we are currently using, a voter only gets one vote. Everybody gets one vote--that is how it is, that is fact. Anybody who doubts that can work through the transfers on this spreadsheet:
https://mcdcselectionsrcvprdst.blob.core.windows.net/public-reports-v2/e7bf14d2-d0db-4c15-bc61-e95482d2a42f/c9b5fc89-8c76-4db1-b1e5-a4618f882dfe/2024-12-02_15-04-55_report_official.html?sv=2026-02-06&se=2026-10-18T13%3A39%3A09Z&sr=b&sp=r&sig=h4XmHEjsBDoYivyu8BQZrwFhG59AYpAQyCi1XnewgxA%3D
As far who funded the charter reform measure, and what the committee thought they were getting regarding representation of racial minorities--I agree with you. Portland is obsessed with race, and I think the committee members had an incorrect understanding of "minority" which was limited to racial/ethnic minorities.
Eberhard explains the more expansive definition of "minority" that multi-member districts and single-transferable vote captures:
"But single-winner districts only guarantee geographical representation. MGGG’s analysis proves that, in Portland, geography is not the same as race and ethnicity. Voters of color won’t have any more power in single-winner districts than they do in Portland’s winner-take-all at-large elections.
The report’s results hold true for other types of minority representation, too. Voters who prefer a champion for renters are in the minority, but because there isn’t a part of the city where all the renters live, districts won’t help. Same for people who are dependent on transit, those who get around by bike, youth, or parents of school-age children. Again, many issues of importance to Portlanders are not determined by geography. Proportional ranked choice voting allows voters to come together and support a candidate of choice based on what is important to them, no matter where they live within the city. If one-fifth of voters prefer a renters’ platform, proportional ranked choice voting will give them the power to elect at least one councilor out of five who will champion renters."
It's that definition of "minority" that your fixes do away with. And they move Portland back to a system where issues that large percentages of Portlanders care about don't win a voice in government.
Also, you write:
"Now ask what that does to an independent voter. If your first choice gets a quarter of the district plus one, she is elected whether or not anyone coordinated. But an independent’s first choice almost never does, because independents don’t agree with each other about who that is. Twenty-one candidates ran in District 4, and the unaffiliated voters spread their first choices across most of them. A quarter of the district voting independently elects nobody. A quarter of the district voting in order elects one."
That's a head-scratcher. It seems like you are assuming that voters are random vote generators. 24.95% of D4 voters ranked Olivia Clark as their first choice; and then Green Arnold and Zimmerman clumped in at over 10% each. So your "unaffiliated voters spread their first choices across most of them" is technically correct, but ignores the more important fact of vote distribution. Votes were not spread evenly, they reflect strong voter-preference for Clark, Green, Arnold and Zimmerman.
(BTW, D4 had 30 candidates, not 21.)
Lisa, 30 candidates, not 21. Corrected.
On Clark we agree, so let’s not pretend otherwise. Your 24.95 percent is my figure in my copy, and she is exactly the case my sentence describes: a candidate whose first choices reach a quarter of the district wins a seat with no help from anyone. The other two seats in D4 were not won that way. They were decided by transfers, and transfers follow the order on the ballot, and in 2024 the order came from organized endorsement cards. Arnold had the most first choices of any challenger and lost on transfers. That is not a head-scratcher. That is the system working as designed.
So here is my position, stated once so no one has to guess at it.
Every voter gets one vote. I have never said otherwise. What I have said is that under this system a vote elects someone only if it is ranked in the order a machine has set. The voter with a card elects a councilor. The voter ranking on her own judgment watches her ballot exhaust before the last seat is filled. The 2024 D4 count shows it. I ran the ballots, I published the method, and I will print a correction the day anyone shows me the result is an artifact of my arithmetic rather than of the rules.
I have no quarrel with Duchin’s mathematics or with the MGGG report. It answered the question the commission asked. The commission did not ask the second question: who, inside the system, ends up holding the ranking pen. The Voting Rights Act standard is whether a group of voters can elect the candidate of their choice. In Portland today the group that can is the group with the best organized list. That is not what the voters were sold in 2022.
What I propose is plain. Nine single-member districts, one vote per voter, a majority to win, lines drawn by a commission the council does not appoint, and a mayor with the authority to be held responsible for results. There may be a better system than that. What we have is not it.
Why it matters for Portland, and not just for D4: a city where every councilor answers to a named neighborhood is a city where potholes, permits, and police response have an owner. A city where councilors answer to the groups that printed their ranking cards is a city where those groups own the agenda and no one owns the street. We have had two years of the second kind. Anyone who thinks it is working should say so in public and defend it. Anyone who agrees it is not should start on the charter language now, because the earliest ballot that can fix it is already close.
Hi Robert,
You conflate the rise of the DSA with the new voting method. But the DSA has been gaining seats across the country in areas that don't use single transferable vote in multi-member districts. So I don't see the causality being as tight as you do.
There is that saying that goes something like, "generals always fight the last war." Your piece is doing that, yet much has changed since the 2024 cycle: the mayor is actively and visibly supporting non-DSA candidates; GoPortlandGo has a slate; FuturePortland has a slate; Max Steele has changed the narrative of how the DSA is seen; you've done that too, give yourself credit; the Oregonian has even wised-up with their frank candidate endorsement piece; the candidates have changed how they are campaigning . . . there is a lot that is different this time round.
So let's give this new method a couple cycles for voters shake off their lazies and start paying attention to local politics, rather than doom-scrolling national/international news and giving a knee-jerk vote to the candidate who best expresses their anger.
You write "in 2024 the order came from organized endorsement cards" and give no supporting evidence. I'm not following much of your analysis. By definition, all ballots are exhausted by the time the last candidate wins. That's how voting works.