9 Comments
User's avatar
rich ovenburg's avatar

We have a better understanding of our city because of the Examiner …..Thanks

Phil Querin's avatar

Allan - your grasp, intelligence and insight make your voice invaluable. Thank you for all that you’re doing.

Scott Spencer's avatar

My main problem with this editorial is that Claussen blames the new charter for problems that existed long before charter reform. He needs to show how the new system makes those problems worse.

Randy Leonard and Jo Ann Hardesty both won citywide elections. Requiring broad citywide appeal clearly didn’t guarantee good temperament or sound judgment. Name recognition has always helped incumbents, too. And Willamette Week left Green and Morillo out of its top three recommendations, showing that incumbents don’t automatically get a newspaper’s strongest support.

The new system reduces the old guard’s advantage; it doesn’t exclude them. Their candidates can win with the same 25% plus one threshold as anyone else. Established connections, recognizable names, and political experience would make them viable and serious candidates—but they need to run.

“Community organizing” and “populist pitches” are loaded phrases. Those descriptions could apply to Obama and Trump, respectively. Neither is new to American politics, so what problem did the charter create?

I share his concerns about the DSA candidates. They haven’t convinced me they are serious about governing. But the same election rules apply to them as everyone else. Their opponents are equally free to organize, recruit candidates, and build voter support.

His concerns about public financing are worth discussing. There should be a reasonable balance between helping candidates compete and protecting public money. But he worries about incumbents becoming entrenched, then criticizes a program that helps challengers compete with them. If tighter funding rules make it harder for lesser-known candidates to get started, that could strengthen the very advantage he complains about.

That brings me back to the headline, “City Council inclusion a one-time deal.” What door has closed to future candidates that was open to the first group? Incumbents had advantages under the old system, and he hasn’t convinced me that the new charter makes them harder to beat.

Ollie Parks's avatar

The comment confuses two different problems. The editorial doesn't argue that the old system elected better people. It argues that the new system makes it harder to get rid of the ones voters come to regret.

Jo Ann Hardesty proves the point. She won citywide, and when a majority soured on her, a majority removed her. That remedy is gone. In a three-seat district, any bloc of 25% plus one that sticks together is mathematically guaranteed a seat. "Their opponents are equally free to organize" is cold comfort. The other 75% can organize perfectly and still cannot dislodge a councilor whose quarter stays loyal. Under the old system, name recognition was an advantage a majority could overcome. Under the new one, name recognition plus a loyal faction is a lock.

What door has closed? The open seat. In 2024 all twelve seats were brand new, and nobody held them. From now on, newcomers run against sitting councilors who need only a quarter of the vote to hold on, and sometimes less. In 2024 the last seat in District 1 went to a candidate with 23%, because he was the last one standing after other ballots ran out of rankings.

The public-financing objection misreads the editorial. The complaint isn't that the program helps challengers. It's that it subsidized candidates who weren't challengers at all. District 4's two DSA-aligned candidates collected $236,000 in matching funds, and when they're eliminated, their votes will mostly transfer to the DSA incumbent. Public money didn't level the field. It paid for a slate.

As for the Willamette Week endorsements, they make the editorial's case. Incumbents winning without a major paper's backing, and without a majority, is what entrenchment looks like.

Scott Spencer's avatar

I understand that a councilor may be harder to vote out when they need only 25% plus one to keep their seat. I think that is a fair tradeoff for giving minority views a voice in City Hall.

I don’t support the more radical views of the DSA candidates. That doesn’t mean their voters should have no representation. The same goes for Olivia Clark. Someone could say the system protects her because she needs only 25% plus one. But those are real voters who support her work. Why should they be unable to elect their preferred candidate simply because the majority dislikes her? In a three-seat district, both groups can have a voice.

You are right that a majority cannot remove a councilor who still has enough support to win one seat. But why should that majority get to choose all representatives from a district?

I’m not denying that incumbents have an advantage. They had that advantage before charter reform, too. A challenger can also win with 25% plus one, without needing majority support.

The Hardesty example makes the tradeoff clear. If she had enough support to earn one of three seats, I would accept that result despite personally disliking her. Her supporters deserve a voice, too.

For me, giving different groups a voice in City Hall is worth accepting that some councilors may be harder to vote out. Whether it’s DSA or its opponents, no group should need majority approval to earn a minority share of the seats.

Talia Giardini's avatar

25% of 1/4 of the city is not “the same election rules apply[ing] to them anyone else.” It’s extremely rare to have multi-member districts where the vote that normally applies to one candidate is split between 3.

A majority of votes should be the only way candidates win, as democracy has been for hundreds of years.Single transferable voting also does not apply to everyone else.

The County is having its first ranked-choice election without either of these odd, and probably unconstitutional, voting algorithms. So we actually have 3 different voting systems between city, state and county.

Talia Giardini's avatar

25% of 1/4 of the city is not “the same election rules apply[ing] to them anyone else.” It’s extremely rare to have multi-member districts where the vote that normally applies to one candidate is split between 3.

A majority of votes should be the only way candidates win, as democracy has been for hundreds of years.Single transferable voting also does not apply to everyone else.

The County is having its first ranked-choice election without either of these odd, and probably unconstitutional, voting algorithms. So we actually have 3 different voting systems between city, state and county.

Thomas Dodson's avatar

Get rid of the government funding entirely. Money does not elect individuals. Candidate personality and ambition and speech and behavior is what voters care about. People vote for who they think will improve the community. Government financing leads to corruption and changes the focus on what is important. I liked the part about how most people are not socialists in Portland.

Mike Burton's avatar

You called it: the voters were so fed up with Portland's one-and-only commissioner form of government that they would have voted for anything, and they did. What they got is a confusing, costly system (each new member gets an aide at a five-figure salary, plus their own salary) and still has a city administrator who crafts the agenda.

Further, incumbents have the advantage of the "public" financing through a polling system that rewards those who get 23 +1 vote (?). At least I think that is how it works.

If you went out on the street and asked anyone (outside the members of the DSA) how this entire system works, I doubt many would understand it.